Stocks, funds or seg funds

Three ways to own the same companies. See what each one takes on, and what it charges for.

For educational purposes only. Simplified illustrations for self-led learning: explore at your own pace, in any order, and use the numbers you choose. Nothing here is based on your circumstances, so it is not financial, investment or tax advice, and not a recommendation.

Three ways to own the same companies. What changes is who picks them, who carries the risk of any one of them, and what is paid for that.

1. Picking the companies yourself

One companyThirty
All the same size (17% each)One dominant holding

Biggest position Everything else

Your biggest position is25%the others hold 15% each
If that one goes to zero25%and you choose what to do next

One company carries a quarter or more of the money, so its news still moves the total.

What a single failure costs depends on how much sits in that company, not on how many names you hold: ten holdings with half the money in one are more exposed than five even ones. Spreading wider also doesn't remove the risk shared by the whole market, which every route still carries.

2. What an ongoing cost adds up to

Nothing3% a year

What $100,000 grows to in 20 years, and how that total splits

You keep$265,330
Goes to the cost$55,38417% of the total

A cost of 1.0% a year sounds small, but it is charged on the whole balance every year, and the dollars paid out stop compounding. Over 20 years that takes 17% of what the money would otherwise have grown to. Whether that is worth paying is what the table below is for.

$100,000 growing at 6% a year before costs, no deposits or withdrawals, no tax. An illustration of how a percentage compounds, not a forecast and not the fee on any particular product.

3. Side by side

FeatureIndividual stocksMutual fundSegregated fund
What you own
Individual stocks
Shares in the companies you pick
Mutual fund
Units of a pooled fund holding many companies
Segregated fund
An insurance contract invested in a pooled fund
Who chooses the holdings
Individual stocks
You, every time
Mutual fund
The fund manager, within the fund's mandate
Segregated fund
The fund manager, within the fund's mandate
Spread across companies
Individual stocks
Only as wide as the companies you buy
Mutual fund
Usually dozens or hundreds at once
Segregated fund
Usually dozens or hundreds at once
Ongoing cost
Individual stocks
No manager fee. You pay to trade, plus any platform charges
Mutual fund
A fee charged every year inside the fund
Segregated fund
Generally higher than a comparable mutual fund, to pay for the guarantees
Guarantee on the money you put in
Individual stocks
None
Mutual fund
None
Segregated fund
Typically 75% to 100% of deposits, at maturity or on death only
What happens on death
Individual stocks
Through the estate, unless the account allows a named beneficiary
Mutual fund
Through the estate, unless the account allows a named beneficiary
Segregated fund
Generally paid directly to a named beneficiary
Possible creditor protection
Individual stocks
No
Mutual fund
Limited, and depends on the type of account
Segregated fund
May apply where certain beneficiaries are named. Not automatic
Your time and decisions
Individual stocks
Research and monitoring, company by company
Mutual fund
The picking is done for you
Segregated fund
The picking is done for you
Who can sell it to you
Individual stocks
An investment dealer, or a self-directed platform
Mutual fund
A mutual fund or securities representative
Segregated fund
A licensed life insurance agent

Every column has ticks and crosses. The useful question isn't which one wins, it's which of these trade-offs matters in a particular situation.

General education, not a recommendation, and not a comparison of any specific products. Costs, guarantees, creditor protection and beneficiary rules vary by product, account and province; Fund Facts, the information folder and the contract always govern.

  • Picking companies yourself concentrates the risk
  • A fund spreads it, and charges a fee each year
  • A seg fund adds insurance features at a higher cost
SeminarsBook a free call